What Telling Men To “Man Up” Does To Them

Chris Williamson

1,491 views • yesterday Save 10 min 4 min read

Video Summary

Men are often taught to suppress emotions, with anger becoming the only socially acceptable outlet, a pattern that can lead to significant mental health issues, including suicide. Despite the societal push for men to "man up," research indicates that over 90% of men who die by suicide have engaged in mental health counseling, suggesting that simply talking isn't enough.

The core issue, according to psychiatrist Chris Williamson, lies in the societal lack of support for male emotional sensitivity. This suppression, often ingrained from childhood, leads to men developing coping mechanisms that can mask deeper struggles. While highly sensitive individuals often possess emotional intelligence and a deep understanding of others, they may face internalized shame and a lack of validation, particularly if their struggles are perceived as stemming from a place of "poverty" rather than "prestige."

Short Highlights

Men are often conditioned to suppress emotions, with anger being the most socially acceptable outlet.
Despite seeking help, over 90% of men who die by suicide have accessed mental health counseling.
Societal expectations discourage men from expressing sadness or vulnerability, leading to internalized shame.
Emotional sensitivity can be a strength, fostering emotional intelligence and deep understanding of others.
The "man points" system suggests men must accumulate "masculinity" before expressing vulnerability.
Societies often validate emotional expression more readily from individuals perceived as having "prestige."
Suppression of emotions is not the same as having composure or not feeling.

Key Details

The Anger Outlet [00:00:00]

Men are often discouraged from expressing a full range of emotions, with societal norms pushing them towards suppression.
Anger frequently emerges as the only socially acceptable emotion for men to express.
This can lead to misdirected anger that may mask underlying emotional sensitivity.

"And as you look at male mental health, I think that we have done a huge disservice to men in terms of we don't educate men and help cultivate with men a lot of information about emotional sensitivity."

Childhood Conditioning [00:00:00]

From a young age, boys and girls are often treated differently regarding emotional expression.
Girls who fall are typically comforted, while boys are often encouraged to move on quickly.
This early conditioning limits opportunities for boys to explore and navigate emotional sensitivity.

"A girl will fall down. They're scooped up. They're, they're coddled. They're told, you know, everything's okay. A boy will fall down and it's like, oh, that's not that big of a deal."

The Paradox of Male Suicide [00:00:00]

There's a societal desire for men to open up about their struggles, particularly concerning male suicide.
However, over 90% of men who die by suicide in the UK have already sought some form of mental health counseling.
This highlights that simply talking or seeking counseling is insufficient if men aren't given space to genuinely feel their emotions.

"So it's not just the talking about it thing. It's actually allowing like giving room for men to be able to feel their feelings."

"Man Points" and Emotional Currency [00:00:00]

The concept of "man points" suggests men need to accumulate perceived masculinity (strength, success, etc.) before they can "afford" to express deep emotions.
Society often views men expressing vulnerability with suspicion, unless they possess significant societal prestige.
This creates a barrier for men who lack these markers of success, despite needing support the most.

"Basically, people have a big ick. Most of society has a big ick with men talking about deep emotions, especially difficult emotions, but they have far fewer if it comes from a place of prestige than one of poverty."

The Challenge of Sensitivity [00:00:00]

Many emotionally sensitive people hide their true feelings due to internalized shame and societal pressure to be "strong."
This leads to performing composure rather than actually possessing it, and denying genuine feelings.
The real difficulty lies not in feeling deeply, but in navigating a world ill-equipped to support that sensitivity.

"The real challenge lies in not feeling deeply, but in living in a world that doesn't always know how to support that sensitivity."

Strengths of Emotional Sensitivity [00:00:00]

Highly emotionally sensitive individuals often possess a deep capacity for emotional intelligence.
This allows for a profound understanding of others' emotional states, beneficial in relationships and professions like psychiatry.
While sensitivity can sometimes negatively impact self-esteem through misinterpretation of social cues, it can also be a source of validation and connection when recognized and valued.

"And I think that's part of, you know, what led me into psychiatry in the first place. That's part of why I've continued to enjoy it as much as I have, because I think that you can intimately understand when people are talking about their experience or like you can even understand..."