Menu
Atty. Justin, KINUMPRONTA ang prosecution: WE ARE MISLED

Atty. Justin, KINUMPRONTA ang prosecution: WE ARE MISLED

DZAR 1026 News

23,215 views • 12 hours ago Save 42 min 6 min read

Video Summary

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a Certificate of Product Registration (CPR) for Kali 88 Foods Corporation's sweetened banana chips, confirming the company's compliance with regulations. This was established through the testimony of Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director for the Center for Food Regulation and Research at the FDA. Despite an initial denial due to labeling inconsistencies and incomplete nutrition facts, Kali 88 Foods Corporation reapplied, addressing the deficiencies. The process involved submitting revised packaging, a Certificate of Analysis, and an Intertech test report to support the product's nutrition information. The court heard that the license to operate was valid during the application period, and the company met all requirements for registration, including those for both local and export markets.

Short Highlights

  • Kali 88 Foods Corporation obtained a Certificate of Product Registration from the FDA for sweetened banana chips.
  • The FDA's Center for Food Regulation and Research confirmed the registration process.
  • An initial application was denied due to labeling inconsistencies and incomplete nutrition facts.
  • Kali 88 Foods Corporation reapplied, addressing the identified deficiencies.
  • The company submitted revised packaging, a Certificate of Analysis, and an Intertech test report.
  • The license to operate was valid during the application period.
  • Kali 88 Foods Corporation met all requirements for product registration.

Key Details

FDA Official's Role and Responsibilities [00:24]

  • Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director for the Center for Food Regulation and Research at the FDA, testified.
  • Her responsibilities include regulating processed food products, processing applications, and evaluating product registrations.
  • "We are offering the testimony of Madame Pillar Marilyn M. Pagayun Pagayunan MBA sorry for the following purposes your honor."

Kali 88 Foods Corporation's Registration [00:53]

  • Pagayunan confirmed issuing a Certificate of Product Registration for Kali 88 Foods Corporation's sweetened banana chips.
  • The registration number was FR4 0000009768567, valid from August 17, 2022, to August 16, 2027.
  • "Number three, Cali 88 Foods Corporation was engaged in lawful legitimate export business of sweetened banana chips and had the requisite license to operate and the certificate of product res registration issued rather by the FDA."

Stipulations and Document Marking [01:47]

  • The prosecution agreed to stipulate on the first and second purposes of the witness's testimony.
  • For the third and fourth purposes, cross-examination was requested.
  • "Uh your honors for the purpose of expediting the proceedings we are willing to stipulate on the first and second purposes and for the third and fourth purposes we are uh going to cross-examine the witness in that regard."

Defense Exhibits Presented [03:05]

  • Several documents produced by the FDA were marked as defense exhibits.
  • These included an FDA letter of denial, an Intertech test report, and Kali 88 Foods Corporation's letters and orders of payment.
  • "Number one, um FDA letter of denial dated February 24, 2022. We request that this be marked as defense exhibit D-2-43-cali 88."

FDA Letter of Denial Explained [12:26]

  • The FDA letter of denial, dated February 24, 2022, was for Kali 88 Foods Corporation.
  • It was issued because of deficiencies found during the evaluation of the application for product registration.
  • "So when it was evaluated there was uh deficiencies that were found and so um if you apply for the product registration it can be the result can be denied and approved."

Grounds for Denial [14:02]

  • The denial was due to inconsistencies in the online application, specifically regarding the declaration of ingredients and validation with the submitted label.
  • The company was required to ensure consistency between uploaded documents and online application details.
  • "Okay. So it was denied because uh the documents there are inconsistency uh your honor in the process of the application the online application the company should uh there's a provision there that you have to specify the list of ingredients and uh in that particular um uh information we have to validate in the label that was submitted."

Reapplication and Addressing Deficiencies [15:46]

  • Kali 88 Foods Corporation submitted a letter on April 30, 2022, informing the FDA of their reapplication.
  • They stated they were addressing the deficiencies identified in the denial letter.
  • "The relation of this letter to the letter of denial. The company um is informing the Food and Drug Administration, your honor, that uh they are now applying for the reapplication and they are addressing the deficiencies that was identified that were identified in the letter of denial and they will be uh filing every application."

Revised Packaging and Labeling [16:47]

  • Photos of the product packaging were attached to the reapplication letter.
  • These were evaluated based on FDA regulations for food labeling, addressing issues like non-declaration of complete nutrition facts and certain claims.
  • "Uh this is the the packaging that was submitted it the initial application and it was uh evaluated in accordance with the regulations on labeling based on the FDA FDA Philippines regulation on food labeling."

Intertech Test Report and Compliance [20:15]

  • The Intertech test report, dated March 29, 2022, was presented as support for the reapplication.
  • It served as an approximate analysis to justify the nutrition facts declaration.
  • "So this is the approximate this is what you called approximate analysis to support the declaration of the nutrition facts rectify now applicant company uh as a as a response to the letter of denial that was issued uh uh that was a while ago right"

Stipulation on Product and Registration [24:19]

  • The prosecution stipulated that Kali 88 Foods Corporation was duly issued a certificate of registration.
  • They further clarified that the company applied for a CPR, submitted requirements including a product sample, and the FDA issued the CPR after processing the application.
  • "Yes, your honor. We are stipulating that Kali 88 applied for a certificate of product registration. They submitted the appropriate requirements including a sample of the product and that the Food and Drug Administration through the Center for Food uh registration and research issued the certificate of product registration after processing the application."

License to Operate Validity Questioned [39:51]

  • During cross-examination, a question arose regarding the validity of the License to Operate (LTO) submitted for the CPR application.
  • The defense argued that the LTO was valid and had been renewed, while the prosecution questioned the lack of an issuance date on the document.
  • "So contrary to what you're saying October 9, 2027 because it was already renewed."

Clarification on Stipulations [41:31]

  • The defense objected to the line of questioning, stating the prosecution had already stipulated to Kali 88's compliance.
  • They requested a back read of the transcript to clarify the exact wording of the stipulations made by the prosecution.
  • "And it is at this point that we will respectfully insist a back read and production of the transcript of stenographic notes because the direction of attorney Ray's cross-examination is diametrically opposed to his previous stipulations."

Witness Competence on Business Operations [47:05]

  • An objection was sustained regarding whether the witness could testify on whether Kali 88 was engaged in lawful export business or track the quantities produced or sold.
  • The court determined this was outside the witness's competence as an FDA official.
  • "So the witness will not be able to answer that. Your honor, we are end I'm ending my cross."

Other People Also See

Your First Million Can Keep You Small
Your First Million Can Keep You Small
Grant Cardone • 8,426 views Save 2 min 3 min read
I Played GTA VI at 60 FPS
I Played GTA VI at 60 FPS
Linus Tech Tips • 29,938 views Save 12 min 4 min read