He Invested in 45 Real Estate Deals. Here's What He Learned
BiggerPockets Money
91 views • 20 hours ago Save 46 min 8 min read
Video Summary
Paul, a real estate investor with 45 deals under his belt, shares insights gained from both passive and active investing. Initially pursuing financial independence through savings, he pivoted to real estate to generate side income and hedge against market risks like sequence of returns. His journey began with single-family homes and BRRRR methods, scaling to multifamily properties and eventually syndications.
Despite early success, Paul experienced significant losses in syndications, with two out of 45 deals resulting in total equity wipeouts due to fraud and market downturns. He emphasizes the importance of diversification and careful underwriting, especially in volatile markets. Paul's current net worth is diversified across stocks (35%), fixed income (10-15%), and real estate (50%), with real estate split between passive (20%) and active (30%) investments. He advises caution against overly hyped deals and encourages investors to act like capital allocators, always asking 'no' first and scrutinizing every investment.
Short Highlights
- Paul's Investment Journey: Began with a FIRE movement goal, transitioned to real estate for income, and scaled from single-family homes to syndications.
- Real Estate Losses: Experienced significant losses in syndications, with two out of 45 deals being total equity wipeouts.
- Diversification Strategy: Holds 50% of net worth in real estate (30% active, 20% passive), balanced with stocks and fixed income.
- Market Caution: Advises investors to act as capital allocators, scrutinize deals, and avoid hype.
- Current Market Outlook: Believes it's a buyer's market with opportunities for well-funded, knowledgeable investors.
- Key Takeaways: Emphasizes diversification, understanding risk, and avoiding correlation in investment portfolios.
- New Book: Authored "Both Sides of the Table" to guide passive real estate investors.
Key Details
The FIRE Pursuit and Real Estate Pivot [00:00]
- Paul initially aimed for financial independence through aggressive saving, inspired by the FIRE movement and figures like Mr. Money Mustache.
- He planned to live off 3% of his principal, but grew concerned about sequence of returns risk.
-
"I found the fire movement, and I thought that that was really sensible."
Transitioning to Real Estate for Income [00:00]
- Seeking supplemental income, Paul turned to real estate around 2010, inspired by house flipping shows.
- He delayed action until 2016, purchasing his first duplex, and then scaled through flipping and the BRRRR method.
-
"I saw real estate as really the path to being able to achieve that."
Leaving the W-2 for Full-Time Investing [00:00]
- Approaching his financial independence goal (65-70% there) and facing frequent travel for his sales job, Paul decided to go all-in on real estate.
- His wife's stable W-2 job provided a safety net and health insurance during this transition.
-
"The biggest risk at this point is not taking a chance of myself."
Financial Strategy: HELOC and BRRRR [00:00]
- Paul paid off his primary residence and immediately took out a HELOC as an insurance policy and capital source.
- He used the HELOC to buy houses in cash, fix them, rent them, and then refinance, repeating the BRRRR method.
-
"I would buy houses in cash with the money from the home equity line of credit."
Scaling Up in a Bull Market [00:00]
- The period of 2019-2020, leading into COVID, saw cheap money, rising rents, and increasing asset values.
- Paul's strategy focused on reducing liabilities, like paying off his mortgage, freeing up cash.
-
"Money got very, very cheap. Rents went up quite a bit. Asset values increased quite a bit."
Diversifying as a Limited Partner (LP) [00:00]
- Starting in 2016, Paul invested as an LP in other operators' deals to gain geographic and asset class diversification.
- He explored self-storage, retail, and mobile home parks, seeking to learn from experienced GPs.
-
"I saw it as a way, I was very interested in commercial real estate, one, but I also saw it as a way to diversify away from myself as an operator or real estate investor."
Becoming a General Partner (GP) and Market Shift [00:00]
- Paul applied his LP learnings to his own operations, becoming a GP and raising capital from other LPs around 2021.
- This coincided with a market shift as interest rates began to rise significantly in 2022, creating headwinds.
-
"And then we scaled into a market that became very difficult starting in 2022."
Syndication Losses and Fraud [00:00]
- Paul experienced significant losses in his LP portfolio, with two deals being total equity wipeouts due to fraud.
- These fraudulent deals involved bad actors, one being an ATM deal and the other a Texas multifamily property.
-
"Two were fraud, so two were bad actors, and some friends were involved in that deal as well."
Navigating Market Downturns [00:00]
- Paul avoided floating-rate debt, opting for fixed-rate loans, which protected him from rising interest rates.
- He underwrote numerous deals in 2022 but secured none, as his underwriting was based on fixed-rate debt and realistic rent growth assumptions.
-
"We stayed away from that. We did not take out any floating rate debt. It was all fixed rate."
Pivot to Debt Funds [00:00]
- As multifamily acquisitions became difficult, Paul's firm pivoted to raising capital for debt funds.
- These funds provide loans to real estate investors, offering a diversified portfolio of loans.
-
"Basically a debt fund is a collection of those types of loans."
Portfolio Allocation [00:00]
- Paul's net worth is approximately 35% in stocks, 10-15% in fixed income (bonds, precious metals), and 50% in real estate.
- Real estate is split between passive LP positions (20%) and active investments (30%) where he is the GP.
-
"And then about 50% is in real estate divided between limited partner positions where I don't play an active role and I've decided to invest in another sponsor."
Market Cycles and Investor Sentiment [00:00]
- Paul views the market as a pendulum swinging between fear and euphoria, advising investors to be greedy when others are fearful.
- He believes the current market, with fear prevalent, presents better buying opportunities than the euphoric market of 2022.
-
"Be greedy when everyone else is fearful and fearful when everyone else is greedy."
The Importance of Underwriting [00:00]
- Paul stresses the need for thorough underwriting, especially when investing passively.
- He cautions against "affinity marketing" and "shiny pitch decks" that lack economic substance.
-
"The default answer from a capital allocator is always no. And they really don't care about a shiny pitch deck. They care about the details."
Developing Pattern Recognition [00:00]
- Paul encourages new LPs to review numerous deals across different asset classes and markets to develop pattern recognition.
- He emphasizes identifying one's risk tolerance and ensuring adequate compensation for the risk taken.
-
"You start to see some of these patterns stick out. And then when you see a good deal that meets your risk tolerance, which I think is extremely important to identify, you know it and you jump on it."
Managing Lumpy Income and Reserves [00:00]
- Paul maintains about six months of living expenses in a high-yield savings account for unpredictable income.
- He also utilizes untapped credit lines (HELOC, business line of credit) and cash value life insurance as additional reserves.
-
"Paramount is to have reserves in tow."
Real Estate Correlation and Concentration Risk [00:00]
- Scott highlights the correlation risk, noting that real estate and stocks can crash simultaneously.
- Paul acknowledges his portfolio's sensitivity to interest rates and the challenges in the current market.
-
"Real estate is not correlated, not highly correlated with stocks. You know, they, they can both crash at the same time."
The Buyer's Market and Future Opportunities [00:00]
- Paul believes it's an attractive time to buy real estate for well-funded, knowledgeable investors, despite elevated interest rates.
- He anticipates opportunities from forced sellers as debt matures at higher rates.
-
"I think today is a better time to buy than 2022 if you can get deals at a decent basis that cashflow day one."
"Both Sides of the Table" Book [00:00]
- Paul's new book, "Both Sides of the Table," serves as a blueprint for passive real estate investing.
- It covers diversification, red flags, debt financing, sponsor communication, and using AI.
-
"My book is really kind of a guide to putting not just the principles of passive investing out there, but kind of the practice of it."
Final Thoughts on Prudence and Cycles [00:00]
- Scott praises Paul's prudent approach, noting that even conservative investors face challenges in the current market.
- He emphasizes that real estate cycles mean tough times can be followed by significant gains.
-
"I think Paul is among the more prudent syndicated real estate investors and passive LPs that I've come across."
The Case Against Over-Concentration in Syndications [00:00]
- Scott argues that syndicated real estate, due to high fees, is a poor choice for the majority of one's investment wealth compared to low-fee index funds.
- He suggests syndications are best for expressing specific investment theses or achieving diversification.
-
"Syndicated real estate asset class, in my opinion, is an absolutely terrible thing to put most or all of your investment wealth in, right? And the reason for it is the fees."