Why Impressive Speed Won’t Be Enough To Sell EVs In The U.S.
CNBC
159,210 views • 8 months ago Save 8 min 8 min read
Video Summary
Electric vehicles (EVs) have significantly surpassed gasoline cars in performance, offering instant torque, lower center of gravity, and unbelievable traction, often exceeding the acceleration of even high-end sports cars. Despite this technological superiority and a better driving experience, EVs are not selling as well in the US as anticipated, particularly after federal tax credits ended. The industry faces challenges with consumer adoption, including charger availability, charging time, range, and the higher price point of EVs, which average $9,000 more than conventional cars. An interesting fact is that the GMC Hummer EV, weighing over 9,000 pounds, can accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in just 2.8 seconds.
The path forward for EVs in the US hinges on addressing these practical concerns and making them more accessible to the mainstream market. While performance was key to legitimizing EVs, future sales success will depend on innovation in charging infrastructure, affordability, and responsible power management. The automotive industry is at a critical juncture, with pure EV companies and legacy automakers facing different stakes in this ongoing electrification race.
Short Highlights
- EVs can accelerate faster than many gas-powered cars, with some achieving 0-60 mph in under 3 seconds, like the 9,000+ pound GMC Hummer EV.
- Performance was crucial in shifting the perception of EVs from "boring" to desirable, with Tesla often credited for this transformation.
- Despite superior performance, EV sales in the US lag behind global markets, especially after federal credits ended.
- Key obstacles to mainstream EV adoption include charger availability, charging time, range anxiety, and higher purchase prices, with EVs costing an average of $9,000 more than conventional cars.
- Future success for EVs depends on addressing practical consumer needs and ensuring responsible power management, alongside continued innovation and affordability.
Key Details
Performance Benchmarks of EVs [00:06]
- EVs can reach speeds of about 120 mph, outperforming many gasoline cars in acceleration and providing a smoother, quieter ride.
- They offer instant torque, a low center of gravity, and excellent traction, making them more dynamic than traditional vehicles.
- High performance was a critical factor in selling EVs to the public, helping to legitimize them beyond the perception of being "glorified golf carts."
"When it comes to performance, today's EVs embarrass gas burning cars."
The Shift in EV Perception [02:11]
- Early EVs were known for being green but were often perceived as boring and lacking excitement.
- Tesla is credited with transforming EVs into desirable items, moving them from a "vegetable you should eat" to a "dessert you desire."
- The introduction of performance models, like the Tesla Roadster, was a strategic move to demonstrate that EVs could be more than utilitarian vehicles.
"They created the seinal product."
Luxury and Performance in EV Market Entry [03:50]
- New technology adoption often starts with luxury products due to the high cost of development.
- Early EV models were marketed to affluent consumers, with speed, design, and style being key selling points.
- Automakers integrated EVs into their high-performance lines, including supercars and hypercars, and even created EV racing series.
"So the models that have come out have been marketed to the affluent and the feature that they want is speed and you know design and style and all that stuff."
Mainstream EV Performance and Sales Figures [04:21]
- Even mainstream EVs offer performance that can easily outperform sports cars from a decade or two ago.
- Large vehicles like the GMC Hummer EV (over 9,000 lbs) can accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in 2.8 seconds.
- The Porsche Macan 4S electric, a four-door crossover, achieves 0-60 mph in under 4 seconds, rivaling some 911 models.
- Approximately one-third of Macan sales have been electric models since the new generation launched.
"Even pickup trucks, crossovers, and family SUVs, some of which are huge, can accelerate at scorching speeds."
The Kia EV6 GT Line: A Mainstream Contender [05:21]
- The Kia EV6 GT line starts at about $59,000, roughly $9,000 more than the average US car price.
- The base model is more affordable, just under $43,000.
- Car and Driver recorded the Kia EV6 GT line accelerating to 60 mph in about 4.5 seconds, making it a mainstream, capable EV.
- The compact/midsize crossover segment and full-size trucks are the two largest segments in the US market.
"So, out of all the cars today, this would be the most mainstream vehicle."
Sales Performance of Hyundai Motor Group EVs [06:06]
- Kia's EV sales have declined through the third quarter compared to the previous year.
- The Hyundai Ioniq 5, sharing underpinnings with the Kia EV6, is selling more than three times as many units in the US.
- Combined, Hyundai Motor Group's EVs would rank as the third best-selling EV portfolio in the country.
"Kia's electric vehicle sales have fallen through the third quarter compared with 2024."
Inherent Advantages of Electric Motors [07:03]
- Electric motors provide maximum torque from rest, resulting in instant response when the accelerator is pressed, unlike internal combustion engines that require revving.
- This immediate torque delivery is responsible for the rapid 0-60 acceleration times seen in EVs.
- Examples of extremely fast EVs include the Model S Plaid, Lucid Air Sapphire, Rimac Nevera, and the Audi RS Ron GT.
"But an electric motor, the maximum torque is there from rest. The response when you press on the throttle is like, wa, and that's fun."
Superior Technology and Sales Discrepancy [08:28]
- EVs are demonstrably as good as, or better than, other vehicles on the road and represent a superior technology compared to combustion vehicles.
- However, sales data shows a sharp decline in EV sales shortly after federal tax credits were rolled back.
- Automakers are reconsidering their all-electric futures, increasing production of gas and hybrid vehicles.
"But sales tell a different story."
Major Obstacles to EV Adoption [09:03]
- Consumer surveys consistently point to charger availability, charging time, range, and price as significant concerns for mainstream EV adoption.
- EVs are pricey, averaging about $9,000 more than the already high price of new cars.
- The aging car fleet in the US, with an average age of around 12 years, and high monthly loan payments exacerbate affordability issues.
"Surveys say the same thing. charger availability, charging time, range, and price."
Challenges with EV Handling and Sensory Experience [09:53]
- While instant torque is appealing, some EVs, particularly those with less refined chassis, don't corner as well as expected, sometimes lacking the feel of an American muscle car.
- Traditional performance cars offer character through engine sound and vibration, elements that are absent in EVs.
- Attempts to simulate these sensory experiences in EVs have been largely unsuccessful and perceived as inauthentic.
"But the minute you hit a corner, it's like an an American muscle car. It just does not corner the way that it should."
Range, Weight, and Safety Considerations for EVs [10:55]
- Gas cars currently maintain high speeds over longer distances more effectively than EVs, which can have less stamina.
- EVs' heavier weight leads to faster tire wear.
- The primary obstacles to EV adoption remain charger availability, charging time, and range anxiety.
"Americans die for our 2% use case. Maybe we only take two road trips a year, but what we buy has to be able to go on those road trips."
Advancements in Charging Infrastructure and EV Design [12:07]
- Charging infrastructure is improving, with technology capable of charging EVs in as little as 5 minutes.
- Pure EV companies and Chinese automakers are designing EVs as "rolling computers" with centralized hardware and continuously updated software.
- This tech-centric approach is expected to be a key battleground for future EV market dominance.
"The rate of improvement of electric vehicles and the charging networks is incredible."
Existential Stakes and the Future of Automotive Innovation [13:00]
- Companies focused solely on EVs face existential stakes, driving innovation and cost reduction.
- Legacy automakers may be more hesitant, potentially protecting short-term cash flows from their gasoline portfolios.
- Straight-line performance in EVs has reached a point where further increases may not be necessary for most consumers.
"It's existential for them."
Safety Concerns and Potential for Tech-Driven Solutions [13:58]
- The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety has warned about the risks associated with the heavier weight and quicker acceleration of EVs, especially concerning pedestrians and occupants of smaller vehicles.
- While insurance loss claims are not necessarily higher, damage losses per claim are worse for EVs, though there are fewer claims overall.
- EVs perform well in crash tests and have earned IIHS Top Safety Pick designations.
- There's an opportunity to leverage EV sensor technology (cameras, radar) to create safer driving environments, potentially by integrating driver education into the car's systems.
"The car can ultimately judge whether or not the driver is reacting to things like strollers and kids."
The Next Phase of EV Adoption [15:45]
- The industry has proven that EVs can perform well, and the focus now shifts to making them more affordable and accessible.
- The next challenge is to make EVs easy to live with, affordable to own, and smart enough to manage their immense power responsibly.
"We've proven that EVs can do the job and now we just have to keep making it better and more affordable so that more people will be inclined to adopt them."