Menu
WARNING: The Two Paths to Recession.

WARNING: The Two Paths to Recession.

Meet Kevin

46,425 views yesterday Save 20 min 5 min read

Video Summary

Two critical "canaries in the coal mine" could plunge the economy into recession, despite a generally bullish market outlook. The first canary signals trouble in the artificial intelligence sector, specifically concerning the circular spending model where companies like NVIDIA invest profits into AI infrastructure firms, which then use that capital to buy more NVIDIA chips. This cycle faces a potential collapse if AI companies like Anthropic fail to demonstrate profitability beyond R&D, despite advancements in AI applications for knowledge workers that could unlock trillions in new market value.

The second canary is the labor market, where conflicting data presents a mixed picture. While some analyses suggest AI has been a net job creator and that construction and AI-related jobs are expanding, others highlight slower wage growth in AI-exposed occupations and a decline in workers' pricing power. This indicates that companies may be capturing AI productivity gains by suppressing wages rather than reducing headcount, disproportionately affecting lower-wage workers and potentially signaling a broader economic downturn if labor market participation normalizes and unemployment rises.

Short Highlights

  • AI Profitability Concerns: The AI sector's circular spending model, reliant on NVIDIA chips and upfront capital injections, faces scrutiny as companies like Anthropic and OpenAI may struggle to show genuine profitability beyond R&D.
  • New AI Markets: Advancements in AI for knowledge workers, such as applications for architects and video editors, could unlock significant new market value, potentially boosting productivity and GDP.
  • Labor Market Ambiguity: Conflicting data exists on AI's impact on jobs, with some studies showing net job creation while others point to suppressed wage growth and declining worker leverage.
  • Wage Suppression: Companies may be using AI to increase productivity and capture gains by suppressing wage growth rather than reducing headcounts, particularly impacting lower-wage and administrative roles.
  • Venture Capital Influence: Studies on AI adoption's impact on company growth are often skewed by focusing on venture-backed startups, excluding bankruptcies and significant job losses.
  • Potential Economic Downturn: A rollover in the labor market, coupled with AI profitability issues, could trigger recession fears and market downturns.

Key Details

AI Profitability and Circular Spending [0:33]

  • The AI sector's spending model is circular, with companies like NVIDIA reinvesting free cash flows into AI infrastructure firms.
  • These firms then use capital injections to purchase more NVIDIA chips, creating a self-reinforcing cycle.
  • This cycle could be threatened if AI companies fail to demonstrate profitability.

    "And it's this crazy cycle."

Anthropic's Financials and Market Potential [1:43]

  • Upcoming IPO documentation for Anthropic (S1 filing) is expected to reveal the company's financials.
  • Concerns exist that Anthropic and OpenAI may attempt to obscure R&D spending to appear profitable.
  • A shift towards AI as a software platform for compliant agents in various industries could unlock new markets.

    "The current estimates we have are that Anthropic and OpenAI are expected to try to hide as much of their spending in R&D as possible."

AI Enhancing Knowledge Worker Productivity [3:24]

  • New AI models, like Astro, are opening markets for knowledge workers beyond coding.
  • AI can enhance productivity for professionals such as architects, 3D modelers, and video editors.
  • This expansion into knowledge work could represent a significant portion of U.S. spending, potentially boosting GDP.

    "And they argue, opens up a whole new market of knowledge workers who can use artificial intelligence."

AI's Impact on Labor Market: Bullish View [7:38]

  • Some analyses suggest AI has been a net job creator, with significant numbers of construction and AI-related jobs emerging.
  • The Economist estimates hundreds of thousands of new jobs in construction and AI fields.
  • LinkedIn's analysis points to substantial growth in AI-specific jobs between 2023 and 2025.

    "The Economist says that we have created 320,000 approximately construction jobs plus 640 to 730 new AI-related jobs because of artificial intelligence."

AI's Impact on Labor Market: Bearish View [10:24]

  • Research indicates that AI implementation is leading to slower wage growth in jobs most exposed to the technology, particularly among younger workers.
  • Companies are capturing AI productivity gains by suppressing wage increases rather than reducing headcounts.
  • Occupations highly exposed to AI have seen declines in real wage growth, with service and lower-tier workers experiencing significant impacts.

    "Companies were capturing AI productivity by suppressing wage gains rather than reducing headcounts."

The "Ramp Study" and Its Limitations [17:51]

  • A study by Ramp suggests companies adopting AI tend to grow faster.
  • However, the study primarily focused on startups and venture-backed firms.
  • It excluded companies that went bankrupt or reduced their workforce significantly, potentially skewing the results.

    "And you removed companies that went from over five employees to under five employees. So the ones that lost employees, you removed the bankrupt ones."

Shifting Workforce Dynamics [21:07]

  • The speaker's company has shifted from a larger G&A staff to a larger R&D team due to AI.
  • While this is a productive shift, it has led to job losses in some areas, even if overall hiring is increasing.
  • This highlights how AI can change the composition of a workforce, even in growing companies.

    "We now have, I think, up to a team of 12 now on developers. But our G&A team is substantially smaller than historical."

Labor Market Uncertainty and Recession Risk [23:09]

  • It remains uncertain whether the labor market will roll over, a key indicator for potential recession.
  • The current labor market is improving, but a shift could trigger recession fears.
  • If the labor market deteriorates, it could slow down the AI software revolution and lead to job losses, potentially triggering a recession.

    "So we're really, dare I say, data dependent. But I guess maybe I should be calling it data trend dependent."

Other People Also See

are we f**k'd
are we f**k'd
Meet Kevin 43,247 views Save 39 min 6 min read
Which Devices in Your Home Are Spying on You?
Which Devices in Your Home Are Spying on You?
Shawn Ryan Show 148,873 views Save 10 min 4 min read