Is Your Coast FI Number Too High? (You're Probably Overestimating)
BiggerPockets Money
7,293 views • yesterday Save 32 min 6 min read
Video Summary
Are you saving for retirement only to realize your financial independence number is impossibly high? This episode of the BiggerPockets Money Podcast reveals how overly conservative assumptions can inflate your target number, potentially forcing you to work years longer than necessary. Hosts Mindy Jensen and Evan Lawler explore the nuances of calculating a "Coast FIRE" number, emphasizing the critical role of realistic investment growth and withdrawal rate assumptions.
They caution against layering excessive safety buffers onto projections, which can lead to a "death march" scenario. By using historically supported rates—like a 7% real growth rate and a 4% safe withdrawal rate—individuals can achieve a more accurate and attainable financial independence goal. The discussion highlights how small changes in these assumptions can drastically alter your projected timeline and the total amount needed, underscoring the importance of grounded financial planning over doomsday scenarios.
Short Highlights
- Coast FIRE vs. Traditional FIRE: Coast FIRE allows for a period of 'coasting' before full retirement, differing from traditional FIRE by factoring in future investment growth.
- Calculating Coast FIRE: Requires projecting current investments, future growth until the Coast FIRE number is reached, and then using safe withdrawal rates for retirement.
- Key Assumptions: Realistic projections rely on historical data for growth rates (e.g., 7% real growth) and withdrawal rates (e.g., 4%).
- The Danger of Over-Conservatism: Stacking multiple conservative assumptions (low growth, high inflation, low withdrawal rates) can exponentially inflate your Coast FIRE number, making it seem unattainable.
- Realistic Projections: Using historically supported rates like 10% nominal growth (7% real growth after 3% inflation) and a 4% safe withdrawal rate provides a more accurate target.
- Impact of Assumptions: A 1% change in investment growth rate or safe withdrawal rate can add years to your Coast FIRE timeline and significantly increase the required savings.
- Achieving Financial Freedom: The goal is financial freedom, not over-accumulation; unrealistic projections can hinder enjoyment and lead to working longer than necessary.
Key Details
Calculating Coast FIRE [00:00:00]
- Coast FIRE calculation is more complex than traditional FIRE due to the 'coasting' phase.
- It involves projecting current investments, their growth to the Coast FIRE number, and then future growth until retirement age.
- Safe withdrawal rates are applied at the desired retirement age.
Calculating your COST-FI number is a little bit more difficult, I believe, than calculating your traditional FIRE number, because there's a couple more steps versus building wealth, reaching traditional financial independence, and then being retired.
Realistic Financial Assumptions [00:01:49]
- Realistic projections use historically supported numbers for growth and withdrawal rates.
- A 10% nominal growth rate (before inflation) and a 7% real growth rate (after inflation) are considered reasonable long-term averages.
- A 4% safe withdrawal rate is a common benchmark for retirement income.
And you wanna use numbers that are backed by a large data set of historic performance, which is what we're using these numbers here today for.
The "Death March to FIRE" [00:05:23]
- An overly aggressive pursuit of FIRE can lead to a less enjoyable life, termed the "Death March to FIRE."
- Coast FIRE offers an alternative, allowing for a more balanced approach while still progressing toward financial independence.
- The concept emphasizes not sacrificing present enjoyment for future goals unnecessarily.
It was just head down, nose to the grindstone, I am gonna get there, come hell or high water, the end, there is no other goal.
The Risk of an Inflated Coast FIRE Number [00:07:05]
- An unnecessarily high Coast FIRE number means working longer than needed.
- Overly conservative assumptions, like very low growth rates or very high withdrawal rates, inflate the target amount.
- This can lead to over-accumulation and years of unnecessary work.
Because in COST-FI you have that period of time where you are coasting, the math is a little bit different.
Impact of Assumption Changes [00:14:12]
- Slightly reducing the assumed investment growth rate can significantly delay reaching Coast FIRE.
- Decreasing the safe withdrawal rate dramatically increases the required Coast FIRE number.
- These changes demonstrate how sensitive the target number is to the underlying assumptions.
So just that small change in assumptions completely changes your Coast Fire age and adds five years of accumulation.
The Power of Realistic Assumptions [00:18:03]
- Using historically average rates (10% nominal growth, 3% inflation, 4% withdrawal) provides a solid baseline.
- Overly conservative assumptions, like an 8% growth rate and a 3% withdrawal rate, can make Coast FIRE seem impossible.
- Playing with calculators helps visualize the impact of different assumptions.
So those assumptions make a huge difference.
Coast FIRE vs. Traditional Retirement Length [00:27:23]
- Coast FIRE often involves a shorter retirement period (30-40 years) compared to very early retirements (50-60 years).
- This shorter timeframe supports the viability of the 4% safe withdrawal rate.
- The 4% rule is a robust starting point for traditional retirement lengths.
So keep that in mind when you're considering what is a reasonable safe withdrawal rate, because that 4% number could be a great number.
Understanding the 4% Rule [00:28:54]
- The 4% rule, developed by Bill Bengen, has a high historical success rate for 30-year retirements.
- It accounts for market fluctuations and inflation.
- Even in challenging economic periods, it generally ensured funds lasted for 30 years.
He found that 4% in every scenario, except I think one year, in every scenario, you have money for 30 years.
Managing Retirement Spending [00:34:10]
- Projecting retirement spending requires careful consideration of future lifestyle and inflation.
- A significant buffer between current spending and projected retirement spending is reasonable, but excessive buffers can be counterproductive.
- Using tools and comparing with similar demographics can help set realistic spending goals.
The real risk, I think, is that you reach age 50. Your goal was to reach Coast Fire, which you do in your early 30s, and you look at your account and you have $6 million and it's all in your tax-advantaged retirement accounts. And you, therefore, cannot retire.
Avoiding Over-Conservatism [00:37:15]
- Stacking multiple layers of conservatism (low growth, high inflation, low withdrawal rates, high spending projections) can create an unattainable Coast FIRE number.
- It's important to have a reason for your assumptions and avoid doomsday scenarios.
- Accurate projections are key to enjoying life and achieving financial freedom, not just accumulating excessive wealth.
And if you put those all together, I'll never reach coast fire.
Tools for Accurate Projections [00:41:06]
- Calculators like Wallet Burst can help visualize the impact of different financial assumptions.
- The BiggerPockets Money website offers resources, templates, and calculators for financial planning.
- Having a solid reason behind each assumption is crucial for effective financial planning.
Play with all of these numbers and see what it does to your expected numbers. It's eye-opening.