Menu
Tesla “Hater” Uses Full Self-Driving for a Month

Tesla “Hater” Uses Full Self-Driving for a Month

Linus Tech Tips

937,776 views • yesterday Save 29 min 8 min read

Video Summary

A month-long test of Tesla's Full Self-Driving (FSD) package reveals a system that is both remarkably capable and frustratingly flawed, often leaving the driver questioning its true autonomy. While the FSD system demonstrated impressive feats, like flawlessly navigating construction zones and complex intersections, it also exhibited moments of alarming unpredictability. These ranged from delivering the driver to the wrong house and nearly causing collisions in parking lots to a refusal to drive due to sun glare on the camera and a concerning disregard for school zone speed limits.

The experience highlighted the system's potential to lull drivers into a false sense of security, with the need for constant vigilance creating a mental load that diminishes the perceived value. Despite moments of genuine awe at the technology's progress, the author concluded that while the system is "so close" to true autonomy, its current price point and the required level of driver alertness make it a difficult recommendation until legislation and reliability catch up.

Short Highlights

  • Impressive Navigation: The FSD system successfully navigated complex scenarios like construction zones, merges, and four-way stops.
  • Unpredictable Behavior: The system exhibited alarming flaws, including incorrect destinations, near-collisions, and ignoring school zones.
  • False Sense of Security: Drivers can be lulled into a false sense of security, requiring constant vigilance.
  • Camera Dependency Issues: Sun glare on the front camera caused the system to refuse to drive.
  • Value Proposition: The high price point and required alertness make the value proposition questionable.
  • Potential for Future Autonomy: The technology is seen as close to true autonomy, with potential for greater value as legislation evolves.
  • Comparison to Human Drivers: The system performed better than most human drivers 99% of the time, but the 1% is critical.

Key Details

A Month of FSD Testing Begins [00:00:00]

  • The experiment involves daily driving with Tesla's "Full Self-Driving" package, now a subscription, to assess its value.
  • The driver will document all experiences, positive and negative, with cameras rolling.
  • The initial drive immediately encountered a problem: the system delivered the driver to the wrong house.

    "This is crazy. It just delivered me to a completely different house, and then just was like, okay, I'm done. You have got to be kidding me right now."

Navigating Construction and Merges [00:01:47]

  • The system took a different route home, leading through a construction zone.
  • Despite initial hesitation at a stop line, the FSD system handled the construction zone and a merge quite well.
  • The driver was impressed with the visualization and the flawless merge, hoping for zero interventions on day one.

    "And all things considered, that was a pretty flawless merge. Like, I think, oh, I've got to find some wood to knock on."

Parking Lot Near-Miss [00:03:30]

  • On the second day, the FSD system attempted to drive the car into another vehicle in a parking lot.
  • This incident was considered a significant intervention, negating the hope for an intervention-free day.
  • The driver noted how easy it is to get a false sense of security with the system.

    "It just tried to freaking plow me into another car in the parking lot. I was this close to declaring day one a no interventions day."

Four-Way Stop and Traffic Flow [00:05:15]

  • The FSD system successfully navigated a four-way stop with other traffic present.
  • It was observed to keep up with the flow of traffic, even exceeding the speed limit in some cases.
  • The driver commented that the system is a better driver than most people 99% of the time, but the 1% is concerning.

    "Most people are a better driver than most people 99% of the time, though."

Parking Lot Struggles [00:07:45]

  • The system struggled to find and execute parking maneuvers in a confusing parking lot.
  • It repeatedly circled the lot, failing to identify or utilize available parking spots.
  • The driver had to intervene and park the car manually.

    "I don't understand how it will park. Yeah, that's the thing. It was circling for a while."

Handling Obstacles and Road Hazards [00:10:00]

  • The FSD system demonstrated competence in handling obstacles like cones, construction, and people walking dogs.
  • It slowed down for a person walking a dog and reacted appropriately to a car turning right on red.
  • The system also handled a situation with a car pulling out of a bus stop smoothly.

    "When I was coming out of our complex, there was someone walking a dog, and they were just kind of, like, off over there, and it slowed down."

Camera Visibility Issues [00:13:00]

  • The car refused to start driving due to a "visibility issue" with the front camera, likely caused by hard light glare.
  • This incident was counted as a disengagement, highlighting the limitations of a camera-only system.
  • The driver expressed frustration with the system's inability to function under specific lighting conditions.

    "Multiple cameras blocked or blinded. Clean them. Like, clean what? Like, the windshield's clean, bro."

Unexpected Detour and Four-Way Stop Mastery [00:14:30]

  • The system took an unexpected detour over a bridge, leading to confusion.
  • However, it later handled a complex four-way stop with multiple vehicles and rules exceptionally well.
  • It also correctly yielded to a bus signaling out of a bus stop.

    "Bravo! Oh, handled a four-way stop like a champ. And that was not an obvious, there's nobody at the intersection, we pull up, we stop, we go through."

Speeding and Lane Positioning [00:16:00]

  • The car was observed traveling 112 mph in a 50 mph zone, keeping up with the flow of traffic.
  • The driver questioned the logic behind maintaining such high speeds, even if matching traffic.
  • The system also demonstrated an ability to ride over lane lines when it sensed it was the correct maneuver.

    "So we're currently going 112 in a 50 zone. Uh, we are keeping up with the flow of traffic, which seems to be the rationale, I guess."

Near Misses and Intervention [00:20:00]

  • The system failed to stop for a pedestrian stepping into the street, requiring driver intervention.
  • It also made a dangerous maneuver by attempting to park in a way that would trap other cars.
  • A particularly bad intervention occurred when the car entered an intersection without a clear path.

    "We were not in a turning lane and it just decided to go for it instead of stopping and waiting for a spot."

Positive Interventions and Road Debris [00:24:00]

  • The system successfully stopped for a child on a scooter who was not visible to the driver.
  • It handled road debris, including an empty cup and a larger hunk of debris, without hesitation.
  • Even in heavy rain, the FSD system continued to operate, though it did display a rain disclaimer.

    "Bravo. Well done. You know, I wasn't sure how I was going to feel on my last day."

Final Assessment and Value Proposition [00:28:00]

  • Despite some critical interventions, the author was impressed by the overall progress and reliability.
  • The price point remains a significant barrier, especially given the required driver alertness.
  • The author believes the value would be undeniable if drivers could legally use the time saved during commutes for other activities.

    "I think for me, the biggest thing is I feel comfortable with it. I think the price point for me personally, still a little high."

Comparison with a Porsche [00:30:00]

  • The conversation shifts to comparing the Tesla experience with driving a Porsche.
  • Worst aspects of the Porsche included finding it in a parking lot due to its commonality and a poor backup camera.
  • Best aspects of the Porsche were its handling and the ability to park itself.

    "Worst thing about driving this car? What? Finding it in a parking lot. Why? I had to memorize your license plate number because everyone drives a Tesla."

FSD Behavior and Safety Concerns [00:33:00]

  • The FSD system's disregard for school zones was a consistent concern.
  • The system's ability to track driver attention was discussed, with a note that it's good for convenience but potentially bad for safety.
  • The driver noted that the system feels more confident and handles road debris better than in previous versions.

    "But, that's crazy that it blows through school zones. It doesn't, like, wouldn't you think that I would know, if you're on a weekend, sure. But, yeah."

Final Thoughts on FSD Value [00:37:00]

  • The author reiterates that while FSD is significantly better than in the past, the price is still too high for the current level of autonomy.
  • The potential for future value is high if legislation allows drivers to utilize commute time productively.
  • A price point of $50 or under per month is suggested as more reasonable.

    "I think, what would the price need to be? I mean, again, I don't even pay for premium. And premium's, like, 15 bucks."

Porsche Key Fob and Air Freshener Saga [00:40:00]

  • The Porsche's key fob battery was dead upon arrival, and the car struggled to start.
  • A strong vanilla air freshener in the Porsche caused nausea for passengers, with multiple units found hidden.
  • The author humorously reflects on the air freshener situation and its impact on the driving experience.

    "Oh, my God, Colton. Are there multiple? One? Yeah, I think I took the one out from there. So, I just never took. There's three."

Other People Also See