Why Putin really doesn't want China to invade Taiwan | Ryan McBeth

The Sun

35,332 views • 23 days ago Save 9 min 4 min read

Video Summary

China faces a sobering reality check regarding a potential invasion of Taiwan: modern warfare is notoriously difficult, and the risk of failure may outweigh the rewards. By observing recent global conflicts—including Russia’s struggle in Ukraine and Israel’s challenges in Gaza—Beijing appears to be reevaluating whether an invasion is truly feasible. The complexity of Joint All Domain Operations (JADO), the logistical nightmare of crossing the Taiwan Strait, and the proliferation of low-cost, lethal drone technology create significant obstacles that could turn a planned military victory into a disastrous quagmire.

Rather than risking a costly conflict, China may favor a "soft" takeover, leveraging political influence to support the pro-China KMT party in future Taiwanese elections. While Xi Jinping has set 2027 as a target for military readiness, his personal legacy and the potential for a forced, desperate decision remain the primary wildcards. Ultimately, the United States and its allies are also evolving, learning from real-world combat to refine air defense and precision strike capabilities, ensuring that any attempt to seize the island would be met with overwhelming, multi-domain resistance.

Short Highlights

Why China may avoid a 2027 invasion:
- War is historically difficult, and recent global conflicts show that even experienced powers struggle to achieve easy victories.
- The U.S. strategy of Joint All Domain Operations (JADO) presents an overwhelming, multi-vector threat China has never faced.
- Logistics across the Taiwan Strait are extremely challenging, limited to two narrow seasonal windows with favorable sea states.
- The proliferation of small, cheap drones has fundamentally changed the battlefield, making conventional invasions riskier.
- China may prefer "buying" Taiwan through political influence, specifically by backing the pro-China KMT party in upcoming elections.
- Xi Jinping’s desire to secure a legacy remains the biggest risk factor for a sudden, irrational military decision.
- The U.S. and its allies are actively learning from recent combat, improving their own defense systems and precision strike capabilities.

Key Details

The Reality of Modern Conflict [00:00]

China is observing recent global wars and concluding that large-scale military success is far from guaranteed.
The speaker compares the unpredictability of war to a "crazy girl" that no one can fix, noting that Russia and Israel have both struggled to achieve their objectives.
"I think the biggest lesson that China has learned from the Iran war is that larger countries with experience in conflict have failed at conflict."

The JADO Challenge [02:30]

America’s Joint All Domain Operations (JADO) doctrine represents a shift from sequential attacks to simultaneous, multi-domain strikes.
China has never dealt with this level of coordinated pressure, which aims to overwhelm defenses in a matter of hours.
"America's current doctrine called JADO or Joint All Domain Operations is essentially 1,000 tornadoes on day one."

Strategic Hurdles and Windows [04:10]

An invasion requires crossing a massive strait while under fire, with only two narrow seasonal windows in April/May and October.
The proliferation of cheap, effective drones has made traditional amphibious landings significantly more dangerous.
"You have a giant porcupine that is Taiwan. You have a massive ocean, massive strait that you have to cross and then keep crossing while Americans and Taiwanese are shooting at you."

The Legacy Risk [05:30]

Xi Jinping’s age and desire to define his historical legacy are the primary drivers that could override military caution.
The U.S. is also gaining combat experience, refining systems like the advanced precision kill weapon to counter drone threats.
"If he wants his legacy to be the reunification of a rogue province, that's when we need to get worried that he might instruct his army, look, I want to do this because I want this to be part of my legacy."

Political Alternatives and Alliances [08:30]

China could attempt a blockade to test the resolve of the U.S. and its allies, particularly while American naval assets are focused on the Middle East.
A soft-power approach through the KMT party in Taiwan’s 2028 elections remains a viable, less destructive path for Beijing.
"If the KMP is elected, you could see closer relations with China. And that's how China kind of softly gets the nose under the camel's tent for just a soft buying of Taiwan."