How Ukraine utilised a layered defence to shoot down a Russian SU-35
The Sun
2,144 views • 19 hours ago
Video Summary
Former Royal Air Force pilot Tim Davies discusses the integration of F-16 fighter jets into Ukraine's air defense strategy. He suggests that the recent reported downing of a Russian Su-35 likely resulted from a coordinated, layered air defense approach rather than a solo engagement by an F-16. This strategy involves utilizing ground-based radar, electronic warfare, and surface-to-air missile systems to detect and target threats while minimizing the vulnerability of airborne assets.
Davies emphasizes that the F-16 variants currently supplied to Ukraine are older models with limited radar capabilities compared to the modern Su-35. He argues that the effectiveness of these aircraft depends heavily on Western-backed command and control networks, which allow for data sharing across the battlefield. The conflict is characterized as a proxy war where the electromagnetic spectrum and electronic warfare play a critical role in maintaining operational security.
Short Highlights
- Ukraine's recent success in downing a Russian fighter likely involved a coordinated, layered air defense system.
- Older F-16 variants supplied to Ukraine rely on Western-provided data to compete with the superior radar range of the Su-35.
- Electronic warfare and the electromagnetic spectrum are identified as critical factors in the current conflict.
- The Royal Air Force and other Western services provide intelligence and training to support Ukrainian operations.
Key Details
Air Combat Dynamics [0:00]
- The Su-35 is described as a superior platform compared to the older F-16 A-B variants currently used by Ukraine.
- F-16s are considered inherently vulnerable if they operate without external support or radar guidance.
-
It's not fair fight at all for the F-16s because they're just very old aircraft.
Layered Air Defense [1:28]
- Ukraine has developed a layered defense system that integrates ground-based radar, surface-to-air missiles, and airborne assets.
- This approach allows fighters to remain undetected by keeping their own radars off until the final engagement.
-
Ideally, you'd have a very long-range radar out in theatre, or multiples of them along the border.
The Role of Intelligence [3:30]
- Western nations provide data and training to help Ukraine build effective command and control chains.
- Electronic warfare is essential for disrupting enemy communications and protecting friendly assets.
-
Electronic warfare is the only warfare that is valid now.
Strategic Challenges [5:00]
- The conflict is characterized as a proxy war, creating vulnerabilities for nations supplying weapons to Ukraine.
- Russia's reliance on standard flight profiles has allowed Ukrainian forces to capitalize on complacency.
-
The whole point of the war, there's so much fog. We call it the fog of war out there.