Labor market is 'frozen in place,' economist says. Plus, Investopedia finds AI bubble worries rising

The current labor market isn't cooling, but rather frozen, with both workers and employers exhibiting hesitancy in making moves. While job growth has been slow, internal data suggests employers have pent-up demand and anticipate increasing hiring over the next 12 months, though economic uncertainty and tariff impacts create hesitation. A recent survey on new hires reveals a shift in their thought processes; job search durations are shorter, employer response times are quicker, and fewer applications are submitted, indicating a better match between skills and job roles. Job hopping is also decreasing as employees prioritize stability and a paycheck over the risks of switching jobs, with flexibility and culture fit now more appealing than higher compensation for those who do switch.

The integration of AI is rapidly transforming job landscapes, required skills, and hiring processes across industries. A majority of new hires and job seekers are leveraging AI for application processes and interview preparation, particularly beneficial for older workers re-entering the workforce, as AI helps bridge experience gaps and provides necessary expertise. Meanwhile, despite a government shutdown, major indices reached record highs, suggesting investors are shrugging off political disruptions and focusing on solid earnings, potential Fed rate cuts, and a light regulatory environment. However, concerns linger about an AI bubble, high valuations across traditional metrics, and the accuracy of government data, leading to skepticism among retail investors.

Retail investors express a mix of optimism and skepticism, driven by high valuations, economic worries, government dysfunction, and rising prices. While the stock market is performing well, particularly in risky assets, the broader economy shows signs of weakness. AI spending is substantial, with projections of a $10 trillion infrastructure buildout, leading to comparisons with the dot-com bubble but noting current companies are still generating revenue and profits. This growth, however, fuels concerns about whether current stock prices have become too high, despite the transformative potential of AI.

• The labor market is currently "frozen," with employers anticipating increased hiring in the next 12 months despite current slowdowns.
• New hires are more targeted in their job searches, and job hopping is decreasing as employees prioritize stability and non-monetary benefits.
• AI is significantly impacting job applications, interview preparation, and skill requirements across industries.
• Despite a government shutdown, the market is reaching record highs, with investors seemingly unconcerned by the disruption.
• Retail investors are experiencing a mix of optimism and skepticism due to high market valuations, concerns about an AI bubble, inflation, and the reliability of government data.

Related Video Summary

• Godfather of AI WARNS: "You Have No Idea What's Coming"
• The Latest in AI: Job Loss, Elon & Sam Altman Chip Race & the "AI Bubble" w/ Brian (Blitzy) & Emad
• How AI is changing the job market, according to an Indeed economist
• 2025: Why JavaScript and React Aren’t the Main Game Anymore.

The Impact of Government Shutdowns on the Labor Market [01:24]

• The primary impact of a government shutdown on the labor market is a delay in the jobs report, which is crucial for business leaders and organizations relying on timely data for decision-making.
• This data gap creates a "blind spot" for decision-makers, potentially impacting consumer confidence and spending due to uncertainty about the current labor market's movement.
• Economists can utilize internal marketplace data from sources like Zip Recruiter, along with data from other organizations, to fill in gaps and provide more timely insights when official government data is unavailable.

The biggest impact from the government shutdown on the labor market is going to be on the jobs report that's supposed to come out on Friday. The a lag in this report is going to really impact a lot of the business leaders and other organizations that rely on this timely data to make decisions about what's going to be coming next.

Current Labor Market Conditions and Future Outlook [02:57]

• The current labor market is not cooling but is described as "frozen in place," with both workers and employers showing reluctance to make significant moves.
• While job growth has remained slow, internal data suggests a "pent-up demand" from employers, with a majority anticipating increased hiring over the next 12 months.
• Economic uncertainty, including the impact of tariffs on prices and business bottom lines, is contributing to hesitancy in decision-making, leading to a sustained pause in hiring.

I wouldn't classify the current labor market as cooling. I would say it's frozen in place. We're seeing a lot of workers and employers both stopping uh any sort of movements.

Survey Insights on New Hires and Job Search Behavior [04:07]

• Focusing on new hires (those employed within the last 6 months) provides insights into their current performance, decisions, and job-seeking strategies.
• New hires are exhibiting a shift in their job search process, characterized by shorter search durations, quicker employer response times, and fewer applications submitted.
• This indicates that new hires are becoming more targeted in their job searches, leading to better matches between their skills and qualifications and the roles they ultimately secure.

new hires really help us understand how people who have gotten jobs within the last 6 months, how they're fairing, what decisions they're making, what types of jobs they're going after.

Shifting Trends in Job Hopping and Compensation [05:02]

• Job hopping is slowing down as employees prioritize stability and a secure paycheck over the potential risks of changing jobs, especially amid market uncertainty.
• For most of the year, job stayers have been rewarded for their loyalty, with job switchers increasingly looking for factors beyond just pay, such as flexibility and culture fit.
• This suggests a preference for long-term job stability and a desire for roles that align with personal preferences rather than solely focusing on higher compensation.

As much as employers are slowing down their hiring, we're seeing employees sticking around in their roles longer is a way to wait out uncertainty in the market.

The Influence of AI on the Job Market [06:08]

• AI is rapidly changing the landscape of jobs, including the skills candidates need and the way hiring processes function across various industries.
• A majority of new hires and job seekers are using AI in their application processes and for interview preparation to enhance their readiness for new roles.
• AI is particularly beneficial for older workers re-entering the workforce, helping to fill experience gaps and providing expertise in unfamiliar workplaces.

AI is changing the way that jobs are showing up, the skills that candidates need to display, the way that hiring process is working.

Market Reaction to Government Shutdown and Economic Data [07:03]

• Major indices, including the S&P 500 and Nasdaq, reached record highs despite the government entering its first shutdown in seven years, indicating the market is largely shrugging off the event.
• Investors appear unconcerned, with yields going down and the dollar and yields moving in sync, which is viewed as a bullish sign.
• The volatility index (VIX) remains relatively low, and the Philly semiconductor index also closed at a record high, contributing to a generally bullish market sentiment.

Shut it down and uh go I mean we were supposed to have a bad month in September according to history and now we got a government shutdown. We got green across across the board.

Alternative Data Sources and Inflation Concerns [08:14]

• The Federal Reserve has access to alternative data sources, such as weekly updates of the ADP estimate, to monitor the labor market even when government data is delayed.
• Inflation is a greater concern than employment for policymakers, who may consult sources like the MIT-Harvard Billion Prices Project for inflation insights.
• A disparity exists between investor perceptions of inflation in the bond market and those of the average person, highlighting the complexity of monitoring inflation.

I'm a little bit more concerned about the direction of inflation, to be honest with you, than I am employment.

Market Performance and Key Sectors [09:45]

• Cryptocurrency, specifically Bitcoin, has seen a positive trend with a 7% gain over five days, indicating a risk-on, bullish momentum in the market.
• Healthcare has experienced a significant surge, with the XLV ETF up 5.6% over two days, a level not seen since the bottom of the pandemic in March 2020, potentially linked to an agreement involving Pfizer.
• The semiconductor sector continues to perform strongly, with both the SOX index and Nvidia reaching record highs.

Healthcare has been in the midst of a two-day surge. This is what happened today. XLV up 3% over the last two days. XLV leading of 5.6%.

Investor Skepticism and AI Bubble Concerns [11:09]

• Recent surveys indicate that retail investors are experiencing skepticism fueled by concerns about an AI bubble and inflation, despite overall optimism.
• Valuations are at record highs, and investors are worried about the economy, government dysfunction, and rising prices, questioning if markets have become overvalued.
• The massive anticipated spending on AI infrastructure, potentially $10 trillion, raises concerns about the sustainability of current valuations, with comparisons to the 1999 dot-com bubble.

It's a little high anxiety market at record highs valuation valuations at record highs concerns every which way you look whether it's the economy whether it's the dysfunction in government whether it's the fact that prices are rising the labor market's slowing everywhere you look there's things to be concerned about and wondering right now if hey have things gotten a little too high.

Investor Holdings and Market Preferences [13:43]

• Top investor holdings closely mirror the NASDAQ 100, with Nvidia being a dominant stock, followed by Apple, Microsoft, and Alphabet.
• There is a concern about concentration in these same popular stocks, although Palantir is noted as a top performer in this group.
• International stocks and gold have seen renewed interest, with gold reaching a record high and cracking the top five investment choices for the first time in surveys conducted since 2020.

Their top holdings look very much like the top of the NASDAQ 100. Nvidia is the top stock in almost all of their portfolios right now.

Investor Confidence in the Fed and Government Data [15:07]

• A majority of investors believe the Federal Reserve is handling monetary policy appropriately and strongly support the Fed's independence.
• Tariffs and reciprocal tariffs are the top concerns for investors, followed by inflation and the accuracy of government data.
• The reliability of government data is crucial for investors to make informed decisions, and a lack of trust in this data creates a challenging investment environment.

Tariffs is number one on that list. Tariffs and reciprocal tariffs followed by inflation. And then they're worried about the accuracy of government data.

Market Resilience and Investor Focus [15:57]

• Investors have become accustomed to government dysfunction, and the market has historically performed well during government shutdowns, with a tendency to rise after they conclude.
• Current investor focus is on growing corporate profits, the prospect of interest rate cuts, and a regulatory environment perceived as favorable to businesses.
• The "bull case" for investors highlights solid earnings, a resilient economy, and potential Fed rate cuts as reasons to remain invested.

No. I think we've gotten pretty used to government dysfunction when it comes to investing and what happens in the stock market. We've had, I don't know, five of these over the last 10 years.