5 Tax Moves to Make Before December 31st
BiggerPockets Money
143 views • 18 hours ago Save 43 min 8 min read
Video Summary
As the year-end approaches, strategic tax planning becomes crucial. This involves making timely decisions about investments, retirement accounts, and charitable giving to potentially lower your tax bill.
Key year-end tax strategies include maxing out employer retirement plans, tax-loss harvesting to offset gains or income, and tax-gain harvesting during lower-income years to reset cost basis. Roth conversions offer a way to pay taxes on pre-tax savings at a potentially lower rate now than in retirement. Additionally, reviewing payroll withholding against projected tax liability is vital to avoid April surprises. These moves are best implemented in the fourth quarter, ideally before the end of November, to allow ample time for processing and to avoid last-minute complications.
Short Highlights
- Maximize employer retirement plans.
- Engage in tax-loss harvesting or tax-gain harvesting.
- Explore Roth conversion opportunities.
- Review payroll withholding against projected tax liability.
- Implement these moves ideally in the fourth quarter.
Key Details
Strategic Tax Moves Before Year-End [0:00]
- The importance of year-end tax planning to lower tax bills.
- Key decisions involve investments, retirement accounts, and charitable giving.
- Five year-end tax moves to review before the deadline.
"Most people don't think about taxes until April 15th, but by then, some of the biggest opportunities to lower your bill for last year are already gone."
Understanding Tax Strategy Based on Income [1:40]
- Taxes are an all-year process, with April revealing the outcome.
- Assess whether it's a higher or lower income year than normal.
- High-income years: Defer taxes or offset income (e.g., maximize pre-tax contributions, tax-loss harvesting).
- Low-income years: Accelerate income or fill buckets (e.g., Roth conversions, tax-gain harvesting).
"If it's higher, we want to look to defer taxes or offset taxes. That income is already recorded, right?"
Five Key Year-End Tax Moves [2:30]
- Max out employer plans (e.g., 401k, 403b).
- Tax-loss harvesting or tax-gain harvesting.
- Roth conversion opportunities.
- Check withholding against projected tax liability.
- Ideal timing: Fourth quarter, but not too early; November-December is optimal.
"And we want to do these ideally as soon as possible. Like, once we're in the fourth quarter, we don't want to wait until December 30th, right?"
The Mechanics of Tax-Loss Harvesting [3:20]
- Sell an investment that has decreased in value to lock in the loss.
- Immediately buy a similar, but not identical, investment to remain invested.
- The loss can offset realized gains and up to $3,000 of ordinary income annually.
- Excess losses carry forward to future years.
"A loss is a tool for a high-income year. And on the opposite side, a gain is a gift in a low-income year, right?"
Navigating 'Substantially Identical' for Wash Sales [5:15]
- The IRS defines 'substantially identical' to prevent wash sales.
- Selling one ETF (e.g., VU) and buying another (e.g., SPY) might trigger a red flag.
- The rule of thumb is to buy something about 70% different.
- Example: Selling Pepsi and buying Coke is acceptable; selling Apple and buying Apple back is not.
"Their definition is essentially, you want to buy something or you can't buy something that is substantially identical."
The Strategy of Tax-Gain Harvesting [6:30]
- Beneficial in a low-income year, especially if in the 0% long-term capital gains tax bracket.
- Example: A married couple with $131,000 gross income could be in the 0% bracket for gains up to $99,000.
- Allows selling up to $70,000 in gains with no tax consequence.
- No wash sale rule applies to gains; you can buy back the same asset.
"Essentially, you're resetting your cost basis. And in years past, I had these down income years where I could have taken advantage and paid, you know, a nominal amount of capital gains."
Considerations for Tax-Gain Harvesting [8:00]
- Resets cost basis, helping future self by reducing future taxable gains.
- Can be disadvantageous if it pushes income over cliffs (e.g., for health insurance subsidies).
- Avoid if it pushes income into higher tax brackets (15% or more), unless there's a specific thesis for repositioning.
- Be aware of the 3.8% net investment income tax surcharge for higher earners.
"It does not net out to the same after-tax terminal value in 20 or 30 years downstream in that scenario."
Roth Conversions: Paying Taxes Now [10:40]
- Choosing when to pay taxes on pre-tax retirement savings.
- Can be used to "top off" a tax bracket in a lower-income year.
- Avoids higher taxes later, especially with Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs).
- Example: Converting funds when in the 12% or 22% bracket to avoid higher future rates.
"So a Roth conversion is essentially choosing when you're going to pay the tax on your pre-tax savings, right?"
Roth Conversion Scenarios [11:40]
- Dire scenario: Convert a large IRA balance if the market has crashed, anticipating a rebound.
- Current market: Pay attention to tax brackets and potential cliffs (e.g., MAGI for subsidies).
- Irreversible decision: Roth conversions cannot be undone after 2018.
- Prioritize: Analyze current income, expected income, and compare with harvesting gains.
"So step one is really like looking at how much of income you've already got, how much of its earned income, capital gains. What do you expect through the end of this year?"
Prioritizing Roth Conversions vs. Gain Harvesting [13:40]
- Prioritize gain harvesting for concentrated stock positions to reduce risk.
- Prioritize Roth conversions if the portfolio is well-diversified and there's significant pre-tax money.
- The goal is to address the biggest risk to the financial plan.
"So from a tax perspective, if we don't want to pull too many levers at once, that would be my first one."
Employer Retirement Plan Deadlines [15:00]
- Contribution deadlines vary: some are December 31st, others April 15th.
- SEP IRA and solo 401k contributions can often be extended to the tax filing deadline.
- For W-2 employees, IRA contributions generally have an April 15th deadline, even with an extension.
"So for most purposes, it's going to be April. But if it is self-employed or some sort of like self, you know, business income, solo 401k, you do have a little bit more flexibility there."
HSA Contribution Nuances [16:10]
- While the general deadline is April 15th, contributing via payroll by December 31st saves FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare).
- Payroll contributions avoid FICA taxes, direct contributions do not.
- This offers a greater tax advantage than a direct contribution made later.
"However, there is a, I don't know if I would call it a trick, but you save more tax money if you contribute to your HSA through payroll because that contribution avoids the FICA taxes."
Catch-Up Contributions and New Rules [17:30]
- Individuals over 50 can make additional catch-up contributions to 401k/403b plans.
- For those aged 60-63, the catch-up contribution limit is higher ($11,250).
- New rule: If earned over $150,000 last year, catch-up contributions must be made as Roth.
"If you earned more than $150,000 last year, your catch-up contributions have to go in as Roth."
Roth IRA Contribution Deadlines [19:00]
- Roth IRA contributions have an April 15th deadline (tax day).
- For backdoor Roth IRA contributions, completing the contribution and conversion before December 31st can simplify the process.
- Conversions are calendar-year based, while contributions can be made for the prior year until April 15th.
"Technically you have until April 15th to make your IRA contribution, right? Let's say it's April 10th, and I make my non-deductible traditional IRA contribution of $7,500, and then I immediately convert it to my Roth."
Lifetime Tax Optimization vs. Annual Minimization [21:40]
- Shift focus from minimizing this year's taxes to minimizing lifetime taxes.
- Consider three seasons: peak earning (deferral), gap years (fill buckets), and RMD/Social Security years (coasting).
- Strategic Roth conversions and gain harvesting are key during gap years.
"Don't focus just on this year. Stop playing, you know, one-year tax defense, if you will."
Checking Withholdings and Final Steps [26:00]
- Review payroll withholdings against projected tax liability quarterly, or at least before year-end.
- Ensure sufficient contributions to 401k to meet the annual maximum.
- Examine brokerage accounts for opportunities with losses or gains.
- Make estimated tax payments if necessary, but updating withholdings is often preferable to avoid timing penalties.
"If you're going to have a tax bill, at least don't let it be a surprise in April. Give yourself a couple months to figure out right?"
Considerations for ACA Subsidies and Real Estate Investors [28:30]
- Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) is critical for ACA health insurance subsidies.
- For real estate investors, aggressive tax deferral strategies (depreciation, cost segregation) can lead to zero tax liability but may create precarious financial situations.
- Dying with assets (stepped-up basis) is often necessary for real estate investor strategies, contrasting with the 'die with zero' philosophy.
"This is all subordinated to your modified adjusted gross income and how that intersects with the cliff and scales your credit."
Resources and Professional Advice [30:30]
- Year-end tax planning is complex and requires ongoing attention.
- Resources include the "moneymoves" checklist, healthcare cost calculators, and tax projection tools.
- Professional advice is recommended, with options for hourly consultations, comprehensive financial planning, and tax-specific services.
- Websites: biggerpocketsmoney.com/moneymoves, biggerpocketsmoney.com/healthcarecosts, biggerpocketsmoney.com/FIPros.
"The goal is lowest minimum lifetime taxes, right? So, you have to understand that just mechanically harvesting is bad in most cases unless you're assuming a huge jump in marginal tax rates or a short time horizon to access the funds."