Comparing GTA VI on Every Console
Linus Tech Tips
1,152,898 views • 19 hours ago Save 15 min 5 min read
Video Summary
The PlayStation 5 Pro emerges as the visual champion in Grand Theft Auto 6, boasting superior global illumination and ray-traced shadows that significantly enhance immersion, even if some minor ray-tracing noise is present. While the PS5 Pro leads, the standard PS5 and Xbox Series X offer comparable experiences, with the PS5 often edging out the Series X in draw distance and color handling. The Xbox Series S lags noticeably behind, exhibiting lower resolution, less detail, and inconsistent frame rates, making it the weakest performer among the consoles tested.
Despite the PS5 Pro's visual dominance, the significant price difference between consoles raises questions about whether the graphical enhancements are worth the cost. The analysis reveals that while the Series S is clearly inferior, the choice between the PS5 and Series X may hinge more on ecosystem preference and price availability, with the PS5 often presenting a better value proposition. The DualSense controller's adaptive triggers on the PS5 are highlighted as an immersive advantage, particularly for driving mechanics.
Short Highlights
- PS5 Pro Dominates Visuals: Features superior global illumination and ray-traced shadows, creating a more immersive experience despite minor noise.
- PS5 vs. Xbox Series X: PS5 often leads in draw distance and color handling, while Series X offers comparable performance.
- Xbox Series S Trails Significantly: Exhibits lower resolution, less detail, and inconsistent frame rates, making it the weakest console performer.
- Price vs. Performance: The substantial cost difference between consoles questions the value of the PS5 Pro's graphical enhancements.
- Ecosystem and Price Key for PS5/Series X: Choice between PS5 and Series X may depend on user preference and availability, with PS5 often offering better value.
- DualSense Controller Advantage: PS5's adaptive triggers enhance immersion, especially in driving mechanics.
- Overall Experience: Even the Series S provides a good-looking game on larger screens, though performance varies.
Key Details
Initial Visual Differences Observed [00:00:00]
- Even before gameplay, significant visual disparities are apparent between console versions.
- The Xbox Series S is immediately distinguishable from a distance due to lower image quality.
- Details like "crinkled glass" and the absence of texture in outfits or flyaway strands of hair on less powerful consoles are noticeable.
"For me, it's the frosted or like crinkled glass. The crinkled glass looks different on every single one of these devices."
Hair and Shadow Detail [00:01:30]
- The advanced strand-based hair system is a key differentiator, with impressive detail on higher-end consoles.
- Ray-traced shadows and global illumination on the PS5 Pro are highlighted as significant improvements.
- The Series S shows noticeable aliasing, while the PS5 Pro exhibits some ray-tracing noise.
"And it's especially noticeable because of the strand-based hair system that they're using apparently across not just the main player characters, but also NPCs, which is insane."
PS5 Pro vs. Standard PS5 Comparison [00:04:00]
- The PS5 Pro is identified as the clear winner, offering superior global illumination and ray-traced shadows.
- Differences between the standard PS5 and PS5 Pro are less pronounced than expected in some areas, particularly hair detail.
- Upscaling techniques, like Sony's work with AMD, may contribute to visual differences between systems.
"I do feel like the PS5 Pro is the clear runaway winner. But what's exciting me about it is not the lack of boiling or noise, but the incredible look of the global illumination and the ray traced shadows."
Xbox Series S vs. Series X Comparison [00:06:00]
- The Series S is described as "softer" than the Series X, with lighting appearing significantly different between PlayStation and Xbox.
- Shadows are more immersive on the PS5 Pro, while the Series S shows last-gen distinctiveness with artifacting around the hair.
- Despite its shortcomings, the Series S is still considered a modern-looking game, but its lower resolution and sharpness are apparent.
"Yeah, the lighting is very different between the PlayStation and the and the Xbox."
Console War: Series X vs. PS5 [00:10:00]
- Noticeable differences exist between the Series X and PS5, particularly in level of detail and color handling.
- The PS5 appears sharper, while the Series X exhibits a "mirage effect" potentially to mask lower resolution.
- Draw distance differences are subtle, with the PS5 potentially having a slight edge.
"The level of detail is shockingly different. Is it just me, or is it handling colors slightly differently as well?"
Performance and Frame Rate [00:15:00]
- The Series S is the first console where framiness or stuttering is consistently noticed, particularly during driving.
- The base PS5 also experiences some chugs, especially when driving at night.
- The Series X reportedly runs more smoothly, suggesting a potential tuning difference between consoles.
"This is the first time I've noticed any framiness is on the Series S."
Final Verdict and Large Screen Experience [00:20:00]
- The PS5 Pro is the clear winner for visual fidelity, though the difference isn't always dramatic enough to justify extreme price premiums.
- The Series S is deemed acceptable, especially on smaller screens or lower resolutions, but clearly lags behind.
- The PS5 and Series X offer comparable experiences, with the choice often boiling down to ecosystem preference and price.
"So with that said, the DualSense is a bit of an X factor. Yeah. I like the adaptive triggers and driving. It feels like I'm a little more connected to the cars."