I Spent Over 10 Hours Upgrading my Controllers

Upgrading Analog Sticks: TMR Technology [00:00:00]

• First-party console controllers, while high quality, often lack innovative features found in cheaper alternatives.
• The video introduces TMR (Tunnel Magneto-Resistant) sticks as a replacement for traditional potentiometer-based analog sticks, which wear down and cause drift.
• TMR sticks use magnets for better reliability and a longer lifespan, consuming less power and being more precise than Hall effect sticks.

  "we're going to start by ditching our flawed potentiometer analog sticks in favor of these tmr ones from ghillie kit"

Controller Modding Scope [00:01:00]

• The table displays numerous upgrade options, but users don't need to perform all of them.
• Both Linus and David will be installing TMR stick replacements, new LED backlit buttons, shell swaps, and new back plates with paddles and trigger stops.
• The DualSense controller will receive additional upgrades: clicky face buttons, D-pad, and a larger battery.

  "we're going to start by ditching our flawed potentiometer analog sticks in favor of these tmr ones from ghillie kit"

Disassembly and Initial Challenges [00:03:00]

• Disassembling controllers reveals accumulated grime, especially in controllers used in shared environments like a minivan.
• Linus has prior experience with modding Xbox controllers, including waterproofing PCBs for water submersion.
• Desoldering vibration motors is a necessary step for some modifications, indicating a more involved process for certain upgrades.

  "you may recall that i made a super special xbox controller once out of gold"

Xbox vs. PlayStation Modding Friendliness [00:04:00]

• Modding Xbox controllers is generally considered more beginner-friendly than modding PlayStation controllers.
• David's DualSense modifications are more complex, including adding a screen to the back, which he regrets due to the difficulty.
• The cost comparison is introduced: David's DualSense mods approach the price of a premium PlayStation Edge controller, while Linus's Xbox mods offer an "elite-ish" experience for less.

  "modding xbox controllers seems much more noob friendly"

Specific Xbox Controller Requirements [00:06:00]

• A specific revision of the Xbox controller (1708) is required for certain modifications.
• Flashing newer firmware onto this model is necessary, a process not officially supported by Microsoft.
• The goal is to upgrade an Xbox One controller to function like a Series One, enabling the use of Microsoft's calibration tool.

  "i had to use a particular revision of the xbox controller in order to do this modification the 1708 to be precise"

Desoldering Joysticks: The Major Hurdle [00:07:00]

• Removing the joystick modules requires significant desoldering and is identified as the most difficult part of the process.
• Some guides suggest destroying the joystick to remove it, but the presenters aim for a less destructive method.
• A specialized joystick desoldering tip is used, but its effectiveness is uncertain.

  "you know how to turn it on uh wow it was just i had a better vantage point"

The Long Road to TMR Sticks [00:11:00]

• After extensive desoldering, both controllers' boards are out, and the new TMR sticks are ready for installation.
• The asymmetrical joystick layout on the DualSense is noted, contrasting with the Xbox controller's symmetrical design.
• The smoothness of the TMR sticks is immediately apparent, even before full installation.

  "man even before i put these on you can really feel how much smoother the motion is"

Assembly and Unexpected Complications [00:16:00]

• The reassembly process is challenging, requiring careful attention to guides and the order of operations, especially when combining multiple mods.
• Linus encounters issues with LED and clicky button flex boards, requiring precise alignment and delicate handling of ribbon cables.
• David struggles with wire management and aligning components, highlighting the intricate nature of fitting numerous new parts into the existing controller shell.

  "i would say doing any one of these mods fairly straightforward really detailed guides doing them all at the same time the order of operations becomes kind of a challenge"

Final Assembly and Testing [00:28:00]

• Both controllers are nearing completion, with LEDs lighting up and buttons functioning.
• Linus experiences a snapped paddle button, requiring a replacement part.
• Despite the difficulties, the visual results are impressive, with custom color schemes and enhanced aesthetics.

  "holy crap the alignment on this has to be perfect"

Comparing the Modified Controllers [00:35:00]

• The modified controllers are compared to premium options like the PlayStation Edge and Xbox Elite, with the DIY versions proving superior in some aspects.
• The TMR sticks are highlighted as a significant advantage over replaceable potentiometer modules, offering greater longevity.
• While the Edge and Elite have features like adjustable stick tension and software tools, the DIY mods provide a more satisfying and cost-effective upgrade.

  "it'll work not with that attitude come on david"

Testing and Final Verdict [00:40:00]

• The PlayStation controller with its screen is tested, allowing button assignment and demonstrating the functionality of the TMR sticks.
• Linus's Xbox controller also functions correctly, with working brakes, camera changes, and the option to center sticks after firmware upgrade.
• The overall sentiment is that while challenging, the modding process is rewarding, resulting in highly personalized and superior controllers.

  "i feel like clicking sticks becoming a normal thing was the biggest mistake that ever happened on game controllers"

Final Touches and Aesthetic Choices [00:45:00]

• Linus expresses satisfaction with his controller, despite a minor issue with a paddle button, preferring its rigidity over David's more flexible paddles.
• David appreciates the screen functionality on his controller, even if the paddle feel is less ideal.
• Both acknowledge that while they might make different aesthetic choices if they were to do it again, they are happy with the final results.

  "i'd actually want to press these have a lot of flex to them to do it again"

Battery Upgrade and LED Functionality [00:47:00]

• The significantly larger battery in David's DualSense is noted, rated at 4000 mAh compared to the original's 1350 mAh.
• The LED functionality is tested, with options for single colors or cycling through them, though the individual color selection is questioned.
• The solder mod for the LEDs is preferred over the battery tap method, as it allows the lights to turn on and off with the controller.

  "wow your battery's in how are you are you getting close like no i have to do the whole back assembly now"

The Value Proposition [00:50:00]

• The modified controllers are deemed superior to premium options like the PlayStation Edge, especially considering the cost and effort involved.
• The longevity of the TMR sticks is emphasized as a key benefit over replaceable potentiometer modules.
• The video concludes by reiterating the value of modding existing controllers for a personalized and enhanced gaming experience.

  "this just makes the edge totally irrelevant totally irrelevant and it's cheaper to buy the controller and do all the upgrades yourself"

Reflection on the Modding Process [00:52:00]

• Both presenters reflect on the difficulty and reward of the modding process.
• Linus feels confident he could perform the mods more quickly and efficiently in the future.
• David is waiting to see the long-term functionality before fully committing to doing it again, but acknowledges the satisfaction of the outcome.

  "i need to see it work first yeah then i think i'm ready to answer"

Final Functionality Check [00:54:00]

• The PlayStation controller is connected and tested, confirming the screen and button assignments work.
• The Xbox controller is also confirmed to be fully functional, including its various buttons and features.
• The success of the mods is celebrated, despite the arduous journey.

  "man it looks like ass but it's my ass and it will be my ass if we don't segue to our sponsor squarespace"

Sponsor Segment: Squarespace [00:55:00]

• The video transitions to a Squarespace advertisement, highlighting its website-building capabilities, design tools, e-commerce features, and SEO assistance.
• The ad encourages viewers to visit squarespace.com/ltt for a discount on their first purchase.

  "start building your website today and receive 10 off your first purchase by visiting squarespace.com ltt"

Concluding Thoughts and Future Projects [00:57:00]

• The presenters discuss the possibility of future modding projects, referencing a Vita upgrade and a Game Gear screen upgrade.
• The energy of collaborative struggle during the modding process is highlighted as a positive aspect.

  "how about the time he upgraded his vita while i put a screen upgrade into my game gear"