Paul Kelly on the decade that broke the Liberal Party | Insiders On Background

ABC News In-depth

1,352 views • 6 hours ago Save 24 min 4 min read

Video Summary

Australia’s era of political exceptionalism has collapsed, giving way to a fractured landscape where shared values have disintegrated and effective governance has become increasingly elusive. Political historian Paul Kelly argues that the nation is no longer a world leader in economic and social reform, but is instead plagued by stagnant living standards, budget deficits, and a deep-seated sense of community unhappiness. This crisis of the system transcends party lines, as both Coalition and Labor governments struggle to manage a volatile mix of identity politics, energy transitions, and a challenging geopolitical environment.

The decline was accelerated by the Coalition’s nine-year tenure under Tony Abbott, Malcolm Turnbull, and Scott Morrison—three leaders who failed to reconcile their conflicting ideologies with a shifting middle-class electorate. While Morrison successfully navigated external shocks like the COVID-19 pandemic and trade coercion from China, he ultimately lost the trust of the public. Today, the Liberal Party faces an existential crisis, caught between a desire to appease the rising One Nation movement and the necessity of appealing to urban voters, a strategic trap that threatens to further alienate the party from its core identity.

Short Highlights

Tony Abbott: A muscular conservative who struggled to translate principles into policy and relied heavily on his chief of staff.
Malcolm Turnbull: An optimistic technocrat who failed to manage the ideological divide within his own party.
Scott Morrison: A pragmatic leader who successfully managed COVID-19 and trade coercion but ultimately lost the public's trust.
The Australian middle class has shifted, leaving the Liberal Party without a clear, coherent philosophy.
One Nation’s rise poses a strategic danger; aligning with them could doom the Liberal Party's chances in urban Australia.
Despite political stability under Anthony Albanese, the underlying systemic crisis of governance persists.

Key Details

The Twilight of Exceptionalism [00:03:00]

Australia has moved from a period of pioneering economic and social reform to a cycle of stagnation and division.
The country is no longer a global leader in policy, leading to a decline in community happiness and national performance.

What I argue in the book is that we're now in a new cycle of history, that exceptionalism is gone. Australia no longer leads the world.

A Fractured Nation [00:05:45]

Modern Australia is riven by deep disagreements over identity, climate, and values, representing a disintegration of shared societal goals.
Governments face an unprecedented network of challenges including social media, technological shifts, and the rise of China.

This is a division, not just about values, but the disintegration of shared values, the disintegration of the shared idea of what is virtue?

The Abbott Era [00:10:30]

Tony Abbott was a moralist who struggled to manage his parliamentary colleagues and suffered from an inbuilt contradiction between his conservatism and a progressive nation.
His reliance on chief of staff Peter Credlin was a defining, unusual feature of his leadership, rooted in his own sense of humility and self-doubt.

The other point goes to this extraordinary partnership between Tony Abbott and Peter Credlin. And the heart of this, the heart of this, was Tony Abbott's belief that he could only be a successful prime minister working with Peter Credlin.

The Turnbull Paradox [00:13:30]

Malcolm Turnbull was an optimistic technocrat unequipped to lead a party in an ideological age, trapped by enemies both in front and behind him.
His failure to reinvent climate policy was inevitable, as he had to govern for a broad-based party containing both moderates and conservatives.

He was a rationalist, but he wasn't equipped to lead a political party in an ideological age.

Morrison’s Management [00:16:30]

Scott Morrison was the most significant of the three, successfully navigating the COVID-19 economic response and trade coercion from Beijing.
Despite his effectiveness in managing external crises, he lost the "politics of COVID" to state premiers and was rejected by the electorate in 2022.

I think overall he did very well. He prevailed in terms of China's trade coercion against Australia.

The Future of the Right [00:22:00]

Any attempt by the Liberal Party to form a coalition with One Nation would be a strategic disaster that alienates urban voters and hands Labor a winning narrative.
Appeasement of Pauline Hanson represents a fundamental misunderstanding of the electorate and threatens the Liberal Party's future as a governing force.

Any coalition with Hanson, in which one nation is the major party and the Liberals are the minor party, which seems to be the tacit assumption of some of these arguments, means the end of the Liberal Party.