The $18 BILLION Threat to Strategy's Stock
Coin Bureau
39,459 views • 6 days ago Save 8 min 4 min read
Video Summary
MSCI's new index rules could force billions in stock selling for MicroStrategy, potentially impacting Bitcoin's price. MSCI is differentiating between operating companies and asset holders, and MicroStrategy's business model, heavily reliant on Bitcoin, fails multiple tests. This could lead to index funds dumping MicroStrategy shares, reducing demand and making it harder for the company to fund its Bitcoin purchases through its usual strategy of selling stock.
The company's software segment now represents a mere 0.9% of its assets, with the vast majority tied to Bitcoin. MicroStrategy faces potential exclusion from MSCI indices due to its structure, which MSCI views as an investment vehicle rather than an operating business. This exclusion, while not a delisting or forced Bitcoin sale, could significantly disrupt MicroStrategy's ability to raise capital and continue its Bitcoin acquisition strategy, potentially leading to a reversal of the cycle that previously boosted Bitcoin's price.
Short Highlights
- MSCI's new rules distinguish between operating companies and asset holders, potentially excluding MicroStrategy.
- MicroStrategy's software business is only 0.9% of its assets, with the rest in Bitcoin.
- The company failed four out of five MSCI tests for index inclusion.
- Exclusion from MSCI indices could trigger $1.8 billion in stock selling by index funds.
- This selling pressure could weaken demand for MicroStrategy stock and hinder its Bitcoin buying strategy.
- MicroStrategy is prioritizing preferred stock buybacks over Bitcoin purchases.
- Final MSCI decisions are expected by November 30th.
Key Details
MSCI's New Framework for Indices [0:57]
- MSCI has approved new rules to determine company inclusion in its indices, focusing on operating businesses rather than asset holders.
- The rules aim to exclude investment vehicles that present themselves as operating companies.
"MSCI wants operating companies in its indices, not investment funds presenting themselves as operating companies."
MicroStrategy's Failing Tests [2:28]
- MicroStrategy's software segment constitutes only 0.9% of its assets, making its primary function appear to be holding Bitcoin.
- The company failed four out of five tests under MSCI's new framework for both 2024 and 2025.
- These tests assess the size of operating assets, operating spend, cash flow from operations, and reliance on fundraising.
"The operating assets are tiny because the software business is small next to the Bitcoin pile."
The Impact of Index Exclusion [5:05]
- Removal from MSCI indices would not be a stock market delisting or a forced Bitcoin sale, but would mean dropping out of benchmark indices.
- This exclusion could force index funds, which track MSCI's indices, to sell their MicroStrategy holdings.
- MSCI-linked funds hold an estimated 13 million MicroStrategy shares, valued at approximately $1.8 billion.
"MSCI would pull that block of passive buyers straight out of the loop."
MicroStrategy's Funding Loop Disrupted [6:53]
- MicroStrategy's model relies on raising money, buying Bitcoin, and repeating, often through an at-the-market (ATM) program selling new shares.
- When MicroStrategy's Market Value to Net Asset Value (MNAV) is above 1, selling shares allows it to buy more Bitcoin than it dilutes.
- Index fund buying provides dependable demand, but their potential exit would weaken demand and make fundraising more expensive.
"Fewer natural buyers means weaker demand for the stock, a thinner premium, and more expensive fundraising every time strategy goes back to the ATM."
Shift in Capital Allocation [8:34]
- Recent filings show MicroStrategy spending significantly more on repurchasing its preferred stock (STRC) than on buying Bitcoin.
- In the last three weeks, $561 million was spent on STRC buybacks versus $72 million on Bitcoin.
- The board has increased the STRC buyback authorization from $2 billion to $3 billion, indicating a continued focus on financing over Bitcoin accumulation.
"So, strategy is now spending most of its cash on its own financing, not on stacking sats."
